India is known as a secular country that celebrates its cultural diversity and unity while upholding its democratic values. However, recent developments have triggered a debate over whether freedom of expression is facing increasing restrictions under the BJP’s ‘intolerant politics’.
Two musicians — Punjab-born singer Diljit Dosanjh and Keralam-based singer Pushpavathy Poypadathu — have recently found themselves at the centre of controversies over their performances. Both faced restrictions from authorities in BJP-led administrations, sparking protests and questions about artistic freedom.
Dosanjh landed in controversy after the Madhya Pradesh government attempted to impose restrictions on his concert in Indore. The District Child Protection Officer in Indore issued a notice directing the organisers not to allow the singer to perform four of his songs at the concert scheduled for November 15, over allegations of promoting alcohol and violence.
The curbs are back in headlines after Dosanjh responded to it in his own way by reciting the words of late poet Rahat Indori during his performance in Indore.
"Humare munh se jo nikle wahi sadaqat hai, hamare munh mein tumhari zubaan thodi hai. Agar khilaf hain toh hone do, jaan thodi hai. Sabhi ka khoon hai shamil yahan ki mitti mein, kisi ke baap ka Hindustan thodi hai," he recited before a cheering crowd.
Amid this, a similar controversy was ongoing in India’s southern state. Keralam's capital city, Thiruvananthapuram, witnessed protests over the Corporation's decision to deny permission for singer Pushpavathy Poypadathu's concert at Manaveeyam Veedhi. Protesters accused the BJP-led Corporation of restricting public access to Manaveeyam Veedhi, a popular venue for cultural performances.
Interestingly, both singers faced restrictions imposed by authorities under BJP-led administrations. While officials have offered explanations for their respective decisions, the moves have triggered criticism over their possible implications for fundamental rights and freedom of artistic expression.
Pandit Rao Dharennavar, a professor based in Chandigarh, filed a complaint with the District Child Protection Officer in Indore, seeking restrictions on four of Diljit Dosanjh's songs, including a ban on performing them even if their lyrics were modified.
In his complaint, the professor urged the authorities to prevent the singer from performing 'Patiala Peg', '5 Taara Theke', 'Case (Jeb Vichon Afeem Labhiya)' and 'Jatt Fire Karda' at his November 15 concert in Indore.
The petitioner argued that the songs glorify alcohol, drugs and violence and could adversely influence children. He also requested the authorities to issue directions preventing children from being invited onto the stage, citing concerns over loud music and flashing lights.
Apart from this, the professor expressed strong disapproval of Dosanjh's public performances in which he wears two silver-coloured bullet belts or imitation metal bullets across his chest.
According to the complainant, displaying bullets could promote gun culture and violence.
Acting on Dharennavar's complaint, the District Child Protection Officer under the Women and Child Development Department in Indore issued a directive to the owners of C21, the venue hosting Dosanjh's concert.
The key directions in the notice were:
Although the restrictions followed the professor's complaint, the action has also drawn attention to the wider political controversy surrounding Dosanjh's performances and public positions.
His songs, which often revolve around rebellion, struggle, Sikh history and social justice, have also attracted criticism from right-wing groups.
In October, the Delhi Police had denied permission for the singer to perform at a concert at Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium. The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) criticised the action, alleging that it reflected the BJP's hostility towards Sikhs.
There have also been allegations that the BJP is unhappy with Dosanjh's support for the farmers' agitation and protests over the NEET examination. The AAP has further alleged that the BJP was taking revenge on the singer for refusing to contest the Punjab Assembly elections on a BJP ticket.
It was not just Dosanjh's concerts that reportedly drew the BJP government's ire. His film 'Satluj' also landed in controversy. In July, ZEE5 removed the movie from its platform after the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting cited security concerns.
Playback singer Pushpavathy Poypadathu has also been actively involved in protests through her revolutionary songs. Her songs have also resonated at demonstrations seeking the removal of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar.
The singer from Thrissur, who is also a trained Carnatic musician, lyricist and composer, has used her music to question caste discrimination, inequality and fascism. Questioning the persistence of caste discrimination in society, she has argued that Dalit singers should not be restricted to performing folk songs alone.
The Corporation's decision to deny permission for her concert scheduled for November 14 at Manaveeyam Veedhi has triggered allegations that the move was aimed at restricting her revolutionary music and political expression.
Responding to the decision, Pushpavathy said the BJP would be able to expand its political influence in Kerala only if cultural spaces were eliminated.
"They may be afraid of my songs," she said.
Pushpavathy also questioned the silence of the UDF leadership in Keralam over the issue.
"Is India BJP's ancestral property?" she asked.
"I Just want to continue as a singer. My life is music. The Constitution of India guarantees the right to livelihood to every citizen. My field of work is music."
(Pushpavathy to ReporterWorld)Amid the protests, Thiruvananthapuram Corporation Mayor VV Rajesh courted further controversy with his remarks about the singer, who previously served as the vice-chairperson of the Kerala Sangeetha Nataka Akademi and lent her voice to numerous popular Malayalam film songs.
"More associations are coming forward claiming authority over Manaveeyam Veedhi. How can the Corporation allow this? If any association has the authority to manage the street, there should be a document to establish it. There is no need for a discussion about Pushpavathy or anyone else. Permission for an event is granted after reviewing the grounds. Currently, the state government has authorised the Corporation to manage Manaveeyam Veedhi," he said.
He argued that the Corporation decided to deny permission for the event because multiple associations had announced programmes at the venue on the same day, raising the possibility of clashes.
On November 16, artists and cultural activists joined hands and marched towards the Corporation office to protest against the decision. A demonstration was also organised at Manaveeyam Veedhi as part of the protest.
Manaveeyam Veedhi, a 180-metre stretch connecting the Museum-Vellayambalam Road to Althara Junction, is well known as a cultural corridor in the state capital. An artists' collective called Manaveeyam Theruvorakkoottam has traditionally organised street plays, exhibitions, art shows, film screenings, music performances, dance programmes, magic shows and puppetry along the street.
In short, the stretch has served as a space where artists and activists gather to showcase their work, exchange ideas and express their political and social views. Therefore, the Corporation's decision has triggered concerns over citizens' freedom of expression and access to public cultural spaces.
Both incidents have sparked criticism of the BJP amid ongoing protests against what critics describe as the Union government's promotion of Hindutva politics. While concerns over the influence of certain songs on children and the portrayal of violence formed the basis of the restrictions in Dosanjh's case, the action against both performers has raised broader questions about artistic freedom and the rights of citizens in a democracy.
The controversies have once again brought the relationship between politics, cultural expression and freedom of speech into focus.